The Name of the Wind

The Name of the Wind is a gorgeous case for listening to a brilliant man, and an equally good case for interrupting him.

Patrick Rothfuss's 2007 debut got me in the oldest way a story can: a voice at an inn, promising to tell me how the legend began. I accepted. Several hundred pages later I was still listening, still occasionally wanting to say, yes, Kvothe, but what did the person beside you think? That double reaction is the book for me. Enchantment and impatience, hand in hand.

Book one of The Kingkiller Chronicle is a story about a teenage life told by its older owner. That distinction matters. The younger Kvothe has the need and embarrassment of a boy trying to become someone; the narrator already knows how to arrange that boy into a legend. Rothfuss lets the gap between those versions do much of his most interesting work.

The premise (no spoilers past Kvothe reaching the University)

An innkeeper called Kvothe tells the story of his own life. He begins with a childhood among travelling performers, moves through years of poverty on city streets, and reaches the University, where he hopes to find knowledge that will answer what happened to his family. The publisher sells an account of a gifted young man growing into a feared and famous magician, told in his own voice. Its early promise is simple: what if the person behind a legend could give you his version first?

The University does not make the book a school adventure in the cosy sense. Money, status and access to knowledge all matter. Kvothe wants to learn, but he also wants to eat, to be believed and to get past doors other people may close. Those pressures make his gifts feel less like a prize and more like a thing he has to keep finding room to use.

What works

Rothfuss makes the act of telling feel physical. Kvothe is a performer before he is anything else, and the first-person narration has a musician's feel for pauses, reprises and a carefully placed flourish. When a tale has already announced its hero's reputation, suspense cannot live in whether he becomes noteworthy. It has to live in the gap between the reputation and the cost. Rothfuss understands that, and he can make an ordinary difficulty feel like the hinge of a myth.

I especially admire how the framed narration changes the contract with the reader. We are not staring through a window at a boy's life. We are sitting with a man choosing what to say about it. A polished explanation may be true and still be convenient. A display of wit may cover an old bruise. The book gets richer when I stop treating each elegant sentence as a transparent pane and start hearing the person who selected it.

There is also a stubborn pleasure in how much of Kvothe's struggle is about gaining knowledge rather than collecting victories. Curiosity gives the long book its through line. He is not merely waiting for a prophecy to summon him. He wants answers badly enough to make foolish choices in pursuit of them, which is a much better foundation for a coming-of-age story than effortless talent would be.

The prose is lush, yes, but its better moments have control. Rothfuss knows when to let a sequence slow and when to end a paragraph on one clean note. He can give a small humiliation the weight another novelist reserves for a battle. I put the book down several times to enjoy the rhythm of a paragraph, then resented having put it down. A tidy little trap.

What's polarising

Kvothe can be exhausting company. He is gifted at a remarkable number of things, and the narration is inclined to admire the arrangement. His mistakes are often interesting, but a reader who wants the surrounding cast to resist his gravity more firmly may spend a lot of time with an eyebrow up. I did. It got exercise.

The romance is particularly vulnerable to this imbalance. I can believe in youthful longing and still wish the girl at its centre had more room to exist beyond Kvothe's fascination. When she enters his thoughts, the prose can become so attentive to his feeling that her own remains hazy. Some readers experience that as the point: his account exposes his limits. Others will simply want a fuller character. I belong to both camps on alternate pages.

The novel also enjoys its own delay. University life, money trouble and storytelling detours occupy a huge share of the journey. If you want each hundred pages to close an obvious plot loop, the book may feel as if it has taken out a long lease on the road to the answer. I enjoyed many of those stops, but I did not mistake all of them for necessary ones.

Spice and heat

Heat: 1 of 5, glimpses and kisses. There is no spice to speak of in this first volume; the romantic current is adolescent longing, not a sequence of heated scenes. Kvothe is a teenager through much of the account, and I read that longing as part of his attempt to understand other people. It reads like YA in its school years and setting, though the publisher presents it as epic fantasy for adults.

The harder content is grief, violence and prolonged deprivation. The book's gentler reputation for beautiful prose can obscure how rough Kvothe's circumstances become. I would recommend it to a mature young adult reader who enjoys patient, demanding fantasy, with that warning attached. Pretty sentences are not a safety rail.

Who it's for

Read this if you like stories about how stories get made. Read it if you can forgive a talented narrator for knowing he is talented, and perhaps enjoy catching him in the act. You will need patience for a long apprenticeship to a larger tale. Bring it willingly; the book can smell impatience like a cat can smell medicine.

If what you most want is a brisk quest or an ensemble that shares authority evenly, pick something else for now. The Name of the Wind gives its best rewards to a reader willing to listen closely and argue back in the margins.

Books like The Name of the Wind

• A Wizard of Earthsea by Ursula K. Le Guin, for true names, apprenticeship and the danger of a young magician's certainty.
• The Magicians by Lev Grossman, for a school of magic that will not cure its student's dissatisfaction.
• The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch, for a performer of another kind who knows how to turn a life into a tale.

Finished the book and not ready to leave?

Talk it through with the characters on Fictora