Romancing Mister Bridgerton

Romancing Mister Bridgerton is most romantic when its adored man finally has to earn the attention he has always received for free.

I came for Penelope and stayed for the small, wicked pleasure of watching Colin Bridgerton discover that charm is a splendid entrance and a dreadful personality. Julia Quinn has written a romance in which being noticed is almost a form of power. For years Penelope has supplied the attention. What changes the air between them is her refusal to remain a convenient audience.

That is a stronger hook than the promise of a handsome man noticing the woman everyone else overlooked. I know that promise sells books. I also know it can leave the woman sitting patiently in the corner while the man receives a medal for moving his eyes. Quinn gives Penelope an interior life sharp enough to make the belated glance feel like the beginning of an argument. Thank heavens.

The premise (no spoilers past Colin's return to London)

This is the fourth Bridgertons novel, first published in 2002, and it centres on Colin Bridgerton and Penelope Featherington in Regency London. Penelope has long loved the brother of her best friend. Colin has been abroad; when he returns, he is tired of being treated as an empty headed charmer and of appearing in Lady Whistledown's gossip column. He begins seeing the familiar Penelope differently. Each also has secrets the other does not yet understand.

That is enough to start. The delicious imbalance is already on the table: she believes she knows him because she has watched him for years, while he has the luxury of being surprised that she exists as more than a pleasant fixture. Quinn makes that asymmetry the romance's first obstacle. It is a quieter difficulty than a duel or a stolen inheritance, but it has sharper teeth.

What works

The friends to lovers turn is persuasive because Quinn allows the old familiarity to become uncomfortable. Their conversations have an ease that a first meeting cannot fake, then a new awkwardness begins to leak into the pauses. I liked that the attraction does not arrive as a replacement for friendship. It changes what their friendship can safely hold. One person has been carrying far more knowledge, hope and embarrassment than the other; every tender exchange has that hidden weight.

Quinn's comic timing is strongest when the joke has a victim who can answer back. Penelope's social position gives her plenty of opportunities to be underestimated, but the writing does not make her oblivious to the insult. She can see the room, and that makes her more interesting than a heroine waiting to be polished into visibility. The book's gossip machinery is useful here: reputation is a public story, intimacy is a private correction. Every conversation asks who gets to write the first version of a person.

Colin's dissatisfaction gives him something to do besides look beautiful in a doorway. He wants to be understood as more than a pleasant face and an agreeable manner. That sounds sympathetic until you place it next to Penelope's years of being misread. Quinn lets both desires coexist, which gives the romance its texture. His problem is not ridiculous. His failure to see the resemblance between their problems sometimes is. A man can be wounded by a shallow reading of himself and still hand one to a woman with a smile.

I also appreciate the book's scale. Society is present as pressure, not just scenery. The family noise and the gossip column keep the pair from conducting their emotional education in a vacuum. Quinn understands the small cruelty of being assigned a role in a crowded room: the charming brother, the harmless wallflower. Watching two people start to resist those labels is satisfying in a way that another lavish ball would not be.

What's polarising

Colin's flashes of possessiveness will divide a room faster than a seating plan. When his unease hardens into a demand, I do not find him thrilling; I find him behind on the work. The novel wants his jealousy to reveal feeling, and sometimes it does. Sometimes it makes Penelope's hard won self possession seem like another problem for him to manage. Readers who need a consistently gentle hero may have a rougher time with him than his easy public manner suggests.

There is also a little too much circling around what each person knows and when. Secrecy is built into the premise, but it can turn a lively exchange into another round of emotional bookkeeping. I wanted the novel to trust its best tension, the unequal history between them, rather than keep nudging the machinery of revelation. The middle is charming, then charming again, then politely asks whether I have admired the charm sufficiently. I had. Tea was getting cold.

If you read historical romance for a densely researched account of Regency life, this is probably the wrong door. Quinn's London is calibrated for conversation, embarrassment and the consequences of gossip. I enjoy that priority, but it does mean the setting is more social instrument than lived panorama. The book asks for affection toward a family as much as fascination with an era.

The Colin of it

Colin is cleverer when he stops performing ease. The charm has been an excellent disguise: people expect the agreeable line and allow him to leave before anyone asks what he wants. Penelope's attention once helped keep that arrangement comfortable. As the relationship changes, being truly seen begins to cost him something. That is the version of Colin I find worth the pages.

He does not get a clean pass for feeling misunderstood. The interesting question is whether he can offer Penelope the recognition he demands for himself. Quinn is at her best when the romance turns that question back on him. I could forgive a great deal of his sulking once the book let Penelope be more than the cure for it. The heart of this one is not that a wallflower becomes worthy of notice. She always was. The heart is that a favourite son learns to look properly.

Spice and heat

Heat sits at 3 of 5, open door. There is on-page sexual intimacy, but the book is driven more by accumulated familiarity and changing emotional stakes than by a constant stream of explicit encounters. Expect adult heat with room for conversation on either side of it. If you prefer a closed door, this will cross your line; if you want every chapter to smoulder, you may spend time waiting for the next match.

The sharper discomfort is emotional rather than sexual: Penelope's long unreturned affection and Colin's possessive streak. Neither is treated here as an excuse to stop thinking about what each of them owes the other. I would hand this to a reader who likes tenderness with enough friction to leave a mark.

Who it's for

You want a historical romance about the difference between being liked and being known. You enjoy a heroine with a private spine, a hero whose best quality becomes his blind spot, and family chatter that has teeth. You can accept a male lead who needs correcting, preferably by the woman he assumed would always applaud him. If that sounds exhausting, it might be. If it sounds delicious, pull up a chair and watch him learn to listen.

Books like Romancing Mister Bridgerton

• The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever by Julia Quinn: another long held affection complicated by the danger of loving an idea of someone.
• The Perfect Rake by Anne Gracie: a warmer, older Regency romp with a rake whose attention changes the terms of a wallflower's story.
• A Lady's Guide to Fortune-Hunting by Sophie Irwin: for the social wit and a heroine who understands that manners are a kind of combat.

Finished the book and not ready to leave? Colin Bridgerton is waiting on Fictora.

Talk to Colin Bridgerton