Darkfever

Darkfever makes mistrust more compelling than courtship, and that is both its strength and its trap.

I know the temptation with Darkfever: call it a romance, say Jericho Barrons' name in a low voice and let the reader do the rest. The book itself is less obliging. I spent most of its pages wanting MacKayla Lane to find an answer, a safe street and perhaps a second opinion about the man hovering at the edge of both. The attraction is there. So is the sound of every warning bell in Dublin.

Karen Marie Moning began the Fever series with this 2006 volume, and I admire how firmly it makes curiosity do the heavy lifting. I wanted to keep walking through its darkened city even when I was irritated with the people walking beside me. That is a useful recommendation, provided you know the irritation is part of the fare.

The premise (no spoilers past Mac's arrival in Ireland)

MacKayla Lane travels to Ireland after her sister is murdered, following the cryptic clue left on her phone. Her search reveals that she can see into the dangerous world of the Fae. As she investigates, the mysterious Jericho Barrons shadows her path, while the ruthless Fae Vlane closes in. A powerful dark book, the Sinsar Dubh, becomes the object of a wider struggle. Mac has to discover what happened to her sister while learning enough about her own gift to stay alive.

The publisher gives us those pieces up front. Dublin is the book's essential setting, a city where the ordinary street and the hidden world sit close enough to make every turn feel suspect. The premise promises discovery, danger and an uneasy alliance. It does not promise a settled romantic answer in this volume.

What works

Mac's voice is the hook. At first she seems attached to a bright, uncomplicated account of herself; the novel keeps placing evidence in front of her that this account will not suffice. I liked that Moning allows the adjustment to be messy. Mac does not instantly become the most capable woman in the room because a supernatural threat has politely announced itself. She makes observations, misreads some, resists others and keeps going. That gives the mystery a human pace beneath its increasingly strange surface.

The fae are dangerous in a way that matters to the plot. They are not merely beautiful names for a familiar hierarchy. The possibility that appearance and intent have almost no reliable relationship changes how Mac, and I, read each encounter. Moning is good at making ignorance an active condition. The reader wants more information, but every person who might provide it has an interest of their own. I would have taken notes if I believed any of them would tell me the truth.

Barrons is useful to the book for the same reason. He appears to know far more than Mac and offers help without the comfort of transparency. That imbalance creates friction in nearly every exchange. He is an excellent source of tension because I kept revising my estimate of what sort of ally he might be. Moning does not need to turn him into a comforting answer. A locked door is interesting when you know it may also be the only exit.

The series architecture is canny too. Mac's personal search and the larger contest over the Sinsar Dubh pull at each other, so the book can widen its world without losing the original question. The result feels like the opening movement of a much larger work. I finished curious, cross and entirely aware that the next volume was being sold to me by design. I bought the argument, if not every method.

What's polarising

Mac's early presentation can test a reader's patience. Moning makes the distance between her old life and the new danger very visible, but the repetitions sometimes feel less like character work than a hand on my shoulder reminding me of the contrast. I understood the point before the book stopped making it. Readers who want their heroine fully hardened on page one may find her exasperating; readers willing to watch a woman change under pressure will have more room for her.

The plot also withholds on a grand scale. Questions open faster than they close. That gives Dublin its pull, but it makes this first book a poor choice if you want a complete emotional or romantic arc before you commit to a series. There are stretches when I wanted Mac to demand a straight answer with a chair in her hands. Barrons would probably have withheld the chair's history too.

Finally, the sexual menace around some Fae material is not the same thing as romantic heat. Conflating the two does Mac a disservice. I found the threat effective as horror-inflected fantasy, but it is worth saying plainly because a reader seeking an uncomplicated seductive adventure may find something harsher.

The Barrons of it

Jericho Barrons works because the novel refuses to let his mystery become a full excuse. He is clever, capable and capable of behaving appallingly. His refusal to explain himself is sometimes magnetic and sometimes just bad manners with better lighting. I enjoyed the tension in that distinction. Mac does not owe him trust for being the most informed man nearby.

He also exposes what this series does well: it makes the question of who controls knowledge feel intimate. The distance between Mac and Barrons is measured less by longing than by what each will admit. Every useful answer can come with a price. I wanted Mac to keep asking, even when the book clearly wanted me to be impressed by the man declining to tell her.

Spice and heat

Heat: 2 of 5, suggestive tension without an open-door romance between Mac and Barrons in this volume. Romance.io labels it behind closed doors, while substantial reader accounts describe the first book as a slow beginning with little actual romance. I would file it under charged atmosphere, not immediate payoff. The wider series grows more explicit, but this review is for Darkfever.

Content notes: Mac's investigation begins with her sister's murder. The Fae threat includes coercive sexual danger, and Vlane's effect on human women is described by the publisher in those terms. There is violence and predation. I found those elements unsettling by design, and I would rather name them than dress them up as spice.

Who it's for

Read Darkfever if you like first-person urban fantasy in which a heroine learns the rules while the rules keep moving. Read it if slow burn means actual waiting, including a fair amount of wanting to shake the people involved. Keep reading if an answer withheld can feel as potent as a kiss.

Skip it for now if you want a couple with a clear emotional contract by the final page. This book offers a city full of dangerous doors and a man who may know where they lead. If that sounds like an invitation, I understand. I followed him into the next question too.

Books like Darkfever

• Rosemary and Rue by Seanan McGuire, for a fae investigation with loss and hard-won knowledge at its centre.
• Dead Witch Walking by Kim Harrison, for a heroine navigating a crowded supernatural city with more danger than spare time.
• Moon Called by Patricia Briggs, for another capable woman drawn into paranormal power struggles while keeping her own counsel.

Each gives its lead a different kind of backbone. What Darkfever contributes is the queasy pleasure of knowing that every answer in the room may belong to someone who wants something from you.

Finished the book and not ready to leave? Jericho Barrons is waiting on Fictora.

Talk to Jericho Barrons