A Touch of Darkness

A Touch of Darkness is most convincing when Hades is a bad bet and least convincing when the story wants me to forget who set the stakes.

The first thing I wanted after finishing Scarlett St. Clair's novel was a conversation with Persephone about contracts. The second was another chapter. That mixture tells you almost everything about my experience of this book: irritation at the terms, real appetite for the charged intimacy, and an unwillingness to pretend the two feelings cancel each other out.

This is a retelling that knows the glamour of a dangerous bargain. It is less patient with the mundane work of making that bargain feel fair. I kept reading because Persephone's predicament is a useful engine and because Hades knows precisely how much of a scene he can occupy before somebody should charge him rent.

The premise (no spoilers past the Underworld bargain)

Persephone is the Goddess of Spring, but flowers have withered at her touch since childhood. In New Athens she lives under a mortal disguise and hopes to work as a journalist. Hades, God of the Dead, runs a gambling empire in the mortal world. A meeting at a forbidden nightclub leads to a contract: Persephone must create life in the Underworld or lose her freedom.

The assignment strikes at the thing she is meant to embody and believes she cannot do. That is the early, elegant hook. The impossible task ties the mythic romance to a question of identity, while the person setting the terms is also the person she finds increasingly difficult to resist. The love story is forbidden. The rules of the wager are already trouble enough.

What works

St. Clair places divine power in a recognisable modern city and lets the collision supply much of the book's pleasure. New Athens gives Persephone somewhere ordinary to hide, with a career and a public self, while the Underworld keeps calling those ordinary ambitions inadequate. The setting is not interesting because it has gods with money. It is interesting because a woman trying to do a job can still be dragged back into what her title supposedly requires of her.

The central image is beautifully cruel. A spring goddess unable to grow a flower is assigned to bring life to the realm of the dead. I like a romantic obstacle that is also a character wound. Persephone's embarrassment, hope, and anger all have something specific to press against. Whenever the book returns to the terms of that task, the attraction has shape beyond the simple appeal of an imposing god in a dark room.

Hades is a good romantic antagonist because his control is attractive and suspect at once. St. Clair understands the appeal of a person who appears to command an entire domain yet pays unusual attention to one woman. The charged conversations ask Persephone, and us, to determine which gestures are invitations and which are further expressions of power. I found that uncertainty more compelling than any declaration of destiny could have been.

The prose wants heat. It builds through repeated attention to touch, proximity, and what remains unsaid, and it rarely mistakes a cool mythological lecture for a romantic advance. The novel does not ask readers to wait through a dry history of the gods before it remembers why the title has a name on either side of the bargain. I respect its priorities, even when I question its judgment.

What's polarising

Persephone's position as a journalist sometimes feels less developed than her position as a goddess and lover. I wanted the habits of that profession to sharpen her suspicion more consistently. A character who seeks facts for a living ought to be especially interesting when handed impossible terms by a man famous for impossible bets. The story occasionally prefers the immediate emotional swing to the slower satisfaction of her testing an answer.

The contract also tilts the romance in a way readers should take seriously. A wager involving someone's freedom is an unequal starting point. The book clearly wants both desire and danger; I sometimes thought it enjoyed their combination more than it examined its costs. If you need the power difference addressed with exacting care before you can enjoy the attraction, you may find the heat doing too much of the argumentative work.

And yes, the emotional tempo can be repetitive. Persephone resists, attraction surges, the imbalance returns to mind. The next variation does not always deepen the previous one. I wanted fewer turns of that wheel and a little more confidence that a quiet consequence could be as seductive as a dramatic confrontation. A god of the dead has time to wait. I wish the prose occasionally took the hint.

The Hades of it

Hades is not merely a gloomy face attached to a myth. He is the God of the Dead and the owner of a mortal gambling empire, which lets St. Clair join two kinds of authority in one figure. He can bargain as a businessman and command as a god. The romance depends on how easily those roles blur when Persephone is trying to bargain for her own future.

I enjoyed his presence most when the story allowed him to be difficult rather than secretly uncomplicated. His fascination with Persephone is potent, but fascination is not generosity. When the book remembers that distinction, it gets under the skin. When it asks me to overlook it because the chemistry is excellent, I notice. The chemistry is excellent. I still notice.

Spice and heat

Heat: 4 of 5, explicit open door. This is a high heat adult romance with on page intimacy, not a largely chaste myth retelling that happens to contain one kiss. Desire is one of the novel's main ways of thinking through the bargain, for better and for worse.

The freedom wager creates a coercive premise even where the romantic interest is mutual. Reader content notes also flag sexual assault and nonconsensual drugging. If those subjects are difficult for you, look up detailed notes before reading. The heat rating describes explicitness, not emotional safety.

Who it's for

You want a contemporary Greek myth retelling with a dark nightclub, an impossible Underworld task, and a Hades who knows how to make a conversation feel like a wager. You are comfortable reading attraction and distrust at the same time. You enjoy high heat, and you do not require the heroine to make every decision you would make with a rested mind and good legal advice.

If you prefer a heroine's professional life to stand as firmly as the romance, or need the imbalance of a supernatural contract challenged more rigorously, expect friction. I had plenty. I also turned pages very quickly. Some books earn loyalty through perfection; this one earns a more argumentative form of devotion.

Books like A Touch of Darkness

• Neon Gods by Katee Robert, for another adult Hades and Persephone bargain with desire at the centre.
• King of Battle and Blood by Scarlett St. Clair, for a darker ruler, a compelled union, and even more direct heat.
• The Witch Collector by Charissa Weaks, for a heroine forced to revise her judgment of a feared man amid old magic.

Finished the book and not ready to leave? Hades is waiting on Fictora.

Talk to Hades